Key West Restaurant Reviews

Listed here are the reviews I have made on the restaurants of Key West, Florida. Starting from the latest review first. I often revisit restaurants to take another look so come back often and check them out.

Thirsty Mermaid | Review

Thirsty Mermaid Key West Scallops

Thirsty Mermaid scallops.

Walking around downtown last month I noticed a small, new restaurant on Fleming Street called the Thirsty Mermaid. This weekend we finally found the time to check it out for dinner. Right off the bat we loved the relaxed atmosphere and the coastal decor, and we were excited to try out some different things on the menu.

We started with the clam chowder with Maine lobster, corn and bacon. This was rich and delicious with the different flavors complimenting each other. And bacon makes just about everything taste great!

The island wedge salad was very good. A simple salad made delicious with the bacon and the maytag blue cheese. Also loved the addition of tomatoes to this for some color and more varied flavor.

Thirsty Mermaid Key West Burger

One of the three different burger choices at the Thirsty Mermaid.

The grilled cheese sandwich with cheddar, Monterey jack, brie, bacon and tomato was out of this world. The mixture of cheeses made it creamy and added extra depth to this sandwich. And the accompanying fries were thin and crispy and tasty with just the right amount of salt.

The good ol’ boy burger was a really great hamburger, topped with cheddar, bacon, onion, and tomato. And this was also served with yummy fries. (Do you see a trend here? We really like our bacon!)

Okay, so moving away from the bacon…

The gnocchi and short ribs were billed on the menu as being spicy, but there is just a hint of hotness, so even those that cannot tolerate spice will likely be able to enjoy this dish. The short rib meat was tender and combined nicely with the delicate gnocchi.

Thirsty Mermaid Key West grilled cheese

Thirsty Mermaid’s version of a grilled cheese sandwich.

The diver scallops were prepared perfectly. They were served with a corn relish and fingerling potatoes. The combination of the tastes was nice, but I would have liked for there to be a few more potatoes on the dish so that each bite of scallops could have been accompanied with both the relish and the potato flavor.

 

Thirsty Mermaid also has a nice wine and bar selection to choose from. For the four of us the bill came to a bit more than $150 with tip, so not outrageous. And the service was good as well. The is certainly a spot that we would dine at again.

Before deciding where you are going to eat while visiting Key West or the rest of the Florida Keys, be sure to read my other restaurant reviews too; check out our restaurant review section of this blog.

And to see what is happening on Key West during your visit, check out our Key West Events Calendar to see other upcoming special events. For more information about the fun side of Key West… things to do and see in our island city, go to our Key West Web Site.

Feel free to Email Me if you have any questions about Key West!!

Island Genn
Key West Concierge

Rooftop Cafe | Review

Snapper Special

Snapper Special

Our friends were recently visiting from out of town and we wanted to take them to dinner someplace quiet so that we could catch up with them without having to yell above the noise that is inherent to many downtown eateries. It had been a long time since I last ate at Rooftop Cafe, of which I had great memories. Located on Front Street in the heart of historic Key West, the atmosphere is “Keysy” yet elegant and fit the bill for what we were looking for.  The outdoor rooftop seating provides wonderful views of the downtown area (with this in mind, reservations are highly recommended for the daily brunch and dinner crowds).

The weather was perfect for outdoor dining, so we requested outside seating at a table overlooking Front Street.

Shrimp Basilico

Shrimp Basilico

After ordering drinks, we decided to try a few appetizers. We went with the pork belly, the calamari, and the shrimp and crab cake. I am not a fan of the fatty consistency typical to pork belly so I did not try this appetizer; our friends thought it was decent, although not outstanding. The calamari was also decent; it was not chewy but it was bland, only to be helped out by the accompanying dipping sauce. Unfortunately, the shrimp and crab cake was awful. It smelled and tasted very fishy and I was worried that I may get sick after eating a single bite.

Being disappointed with the appetizers, we were looking forward to our entrees.  I was torn between the scallops and the bouillabaisse; I went with our waitress’ recommendation of the scallops. In hindsight, I should have gone with the bouillabaisse as I had just eaten the best scallops of my life at Seven Fish a few days prior and I knew that they would be hard to

Scallops

Scallops

compare to.  While the scallops at Rooftop were okay, there were too many competing flavors which overpowered the delicate scallops. My husband ordered the shrimp basilico, a combination of shrimp, fresh basil, plum tomatoes, garlic and olive oil over linguini with parmesan. This was a really good dish. The shrimp were cooked perfectly and all of the flavors melded together. And our friends both ordered the snapper special.  I did not try the snapper, although it looked wonderful and they both enjoyed it.

We thought about trying their key lime pie which has been featured in Gourmet Magazine for dessert, but we decided to cap off the evening simply with coffee instead. They did make a good cup of coffee, and we enjoyed talking with our friends over our coffee.

Shrimp and Crab Cake

Shrimp and Crab Cake

The service at Rooftop was wonderful, as was the view and the entire atmosphere. But the food quality was really lacking in my opinion and not worth a final bill of nearly $300 with gratuity. I think that Rooftop is the perfect place to enjoy fine service, a  relaxed atmosphere, and a few drinks, but it will probably be a very long time before I eat here again.

Before deciding where you are going to eat while visiting Key West or the rest of the Florida Keys, be sure to read my other restaurant reviews too; check out our restaurant review section of this blog as well as our previous restaurant reviews.

And to see what is happening on Key West during your visit, check out our Key West Events Calendar to see other upcoming special events. For more information about the fun side of Key West… things to do and see in our island city, go to our Key West Web Site.

Feel free to Email Me if you have any questions about Key West!!

Island Genn
Key West Concierge

Lucy’s Retired Surfers Bar & Restaurant | Review

Shrimp and Grits at Lucy's Retired Surfers Bar and Restaurant in Key West.

Shrimp and Grits at Lucy’s Retired Surfers Bar and Restaurant in Key West.

I enjoy trying different places to eat, and when I heard that a new restaurant opened where Finnegan’s Wake used to be, my husband and I decided to check it out. We headed over to Caroline Street, parked in the parking garage, and walked around the corner to Lucy’s Retired Surfers Bar & Restaurant.  We were expecting the eatery’s atmosphere to be laid back and fun with some Beach Boys tunes (or something similar) playing in the background; what we walked into could not have been more different. Not only was the live music (not remotely like the Beach Boys) blazingly loud, but the noise of people yelling over the music and the metal chairs scraping on the ground were just too much. The cacophony was overwhelming and we almost decided to go someplace else. We thought that eating outside and away from the music would be better. It was, but not by much. We still practically had to shout at one another to be heard.

We tried the homemade chips and salsa and the queso blanco (white cheeses melted and spiced up with seasonings and tomatoes) to start. The salsa was extremely bland; loading it with extra salt was the only way to give it some kind of flavor. The queso blanco was more flavorful, but it tasted like Velveeta cheese sauce that you can make at home. Definitely not restaurant quality.

The Valley Girl Club Sandwich at Lucy's Retired Surfers Bar and Restaurant in Key West.

The Valley Girl Club Sandwich at Lucy’s Retired Surfers Bar and Restaurant in Key West.

For entrees, I ordered the shrimp and grits and Steven ordered the club sandwich with fries. The grits portion of my meal was not bad, but the shrimp were over-cooked and over-seasoned. I didn’t even finish eating them they were so bad. Wish they had put some of that seasoning into the salsa! The club sandwich was better, with turkey, ham, bacon, and Swiss cheese paired with sprouts, cucumbers, avocados, lettuce, and tomatoes. Loved the fresh veggies.

From what we experienced, Lucy’s serves overpriced bar food in an extremely noisy atmosphere. The saving grace to the place was the staff. Our server was personable as were the other servers working our area. We asked a few of them about the origins of the bar and the name Lucy. Our waiter told us that the bar was named for the Beatles song, Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds. Another waitress told us that Lucy was the girl that got away and broke the owner’s heart. Either way, at least the staff was entertaining! We were also told that there is another Lucy’s in New Orleans as well. I will know not to try that one if I ever make it to the Big Easy!

Before deciding where you are going to eat while visiting Key West or the rest of the Florida Keys, be sure to read my other restaurant reviews too; check out our restaurant review section of this blog as well as our previous restaurant reviews.

And to see what is happening on Key West during your visit, check out our Key West Events Calendar to see other upcoming special events. For more information about the fun side of Key West… things to do and see in our island city, go to our Key West Web Site.

Feel free to Email Me if you have any questions about Key West!!

Island Genn

Key West Concierge

Seven Fish Restaurant Review

My husband and I decided that our Friday date night would be dinner at Seven Fish, and I was super excited! Thankfully, I called to make reservations. If I hadn’t, our date night would have been ruined as they only had two slots still opened! So the moral of the story is, make reservations if you are planning on eating here! When we arrived for our 6:00pm reservation, we were immediately taken to our table. I was amazed that the restaurant was already quite busy as they open at 6:00pm nightly!

I have always liked Seven Fish, but rarely did I go there because the building was so small and parking was impossible! Well, that is no longer an issue, as this staple Key West restaurant has just moved into their brand new building on 921 Truman Ave. After a two month construction delay, the owners finally decided to open. There are a few more finishing touches that still need completion, hopefully warming up the interior of the new, large, very modern and sleek building.

Sea Scallops served with mashed potatoes, pea puree, and spinach as served at Key West's Seven Fish.

Sea Scallops served with mashed potatoes, pea puree, and spinach as served at Key West’s Seven Fish.

Seven Fish had two sushi roll specials, one was spicy tuna and the other was baked grouper. We decided to try both. Since I like spicy food, the tuna was my favorite. The roll had a slightly creamy consistency, and there was a faint hint of onion paired with the fresh tuna. It was delicious. The grouper roll was my husband’s favorite, as the taste of fresh grouper prevailed, and he loves eating unadulterated, fresh fish. Each roll was presented in 5 pieces with the traditional wasabi, ginger, and soy sauce. Unfortunately, even though it was beautifully presented, I cannot share pictures since we dug in quickly and were gone before we knew it!

We then shared a very tasty small mixed green salad with a balsamic vinaigrette. This was served with a piece of delicious, hearty bread topped with salt, roasted garlic, and some spices.

The signature dessert at Seven Fish, strawberry whipped cream pie.

The signature dessert at Seven Fish, strawberry whipped cream pie.

For our entrees, we knew that we would order seafood, but there were so many choices. Typically, I order the crab and shiitake mushroom pasta which I love. However, I decided to go with something different this time, and was torn between the gnocchi with blue cheese and fish or the sea scallops over mashed potatoes, puree pea, and spinach. My husband is a Key West fishing guide, so I eat a lot of local fish already; I decided on the scallops.  Steven ordered seafood marinara pasta with grilled fish, baby clams, and shrimp. We were both very please with our choices.

My scallops were the best scallops I have ever eaten. They were cooked to perfection, and the flavors of the scallops with the potatoes, garlic, spinach, and peas was magical. This was so good, I am in danger of never eating anything else here ever again!

I traded one of my five scallops for a couple of bites of my husband’s seafood pasta dish. This was delicious and he loved it. Again, the seafood was cooked to perfection and the tastes of this mingled with the angel hair pasta and marinara sauce was yummy. And while I could taste oregano and other seasonings in the sauce, it did not overpower the seafood.

Even though we were full, we decided to try the restaurant’s signature dessert, the strawberry whipped cream pie. It is basically a graham cracker crust topped with chocolate and then topped with fresh strawberries and whipped cream. I love strawberries and cream and my husband loves chocolate and graham crackers, so we each had our favorite part of the pie that we ended up eating. If I had not been sharing, I would have ordered the Key lime cheesecake, so that will have to wait until next time to try!

By the way, the coffee that we had with dessert was amazing. Love capping off an amazing meal with a truly good cup of coffee.

I have been remiss in not mentioning the service until now. Simply put, it was great! Not only was everyone very friendly and helpful with suggestions, we never had to wait for drink refills or anything. On top of that, they all seemed genuinely happy to be at work which is something that I am not used to seeing at a lot of places. I loved that they were not over the top hovering over us or snooty like servers at some upscale restaurants can be. It was the perfect amount of pleasant attentiveness that helped to make the meal that much more enjoyable.

Seven Fish is a must try for anyone visiting Key West! So happy that they are back!

Before deciding where you are going to eat while visiting Key West or the rest of the Florida Keys, be sure to read my other restaurant reviews too; check out our restaurant review section of this blog as well as our previous restaurant reviews.

And to see what is happening on Key West during your visit, check out our Key West Events Calendar to see other upcoming special events. For more information about the fun side of Key West… things to do and see in our island city, go to our Key West Web Site.

Feel free to Email Me if you have any questions about Key West!!

Island Genn
Key West Concierge