Are you planning on spending Thanksgiving 2025 in Key West? Well, this is your ultimate guide to how to spend this foodie holiday in our island town. Whether you are looking for a traditional turkey dinner, or you want something with island flair, you will find a restaurant here to accommodate your desires. Plus, learn about other activities that you can do to celebrate before you eat yourself into a food coma!

We will be updating this list as we get closer to Thanksgiving day and the information comes in, so please check back often. We highly recommend making reservations ASAP to wherever you choose as seating is limited and many places will sell out!

If you are a local restaurant owner or manager and would like to have your establishments listed here, please reach out to us: islandgenn@me.com.

Restaurants

You will find that most restaurants remain open on Thanksgiving in Key West. It is a food related holiday so that only stands to reason. The list below are places that will be open. Some have holiday specials and others do not. Some will be taking reservations while other, more casual places will not. The main point is that you will find no shortage a places to dine on Thanksgiving Day in Key West. And, no matter what type of cuisine you want, you will likely find it available on our island. From traditional holiday fare to local favorites, you won’t be disappointed!

Alonzo’s Oyster Bar – 700 Front Street, (305) 600-3405.

Antonia’s – 615 Duval Street, (305) 294-6565.

Atlas Izakaya – 500 Truman Avenue, #7, (305) 998-4189.

Bagatelle – Enjoy holiday specials as well as their regular menu! 115 Duval Street, (305) 296-6609.

Banana Cafe – Serving a special Thanksgiving menu from noon until they run out! 1215 Duval Street, (305) 294-7227.

Bel Mare – Offering their regular menu as well as a turkey dinner special if you prefer. 700 Front Street, (305) 396-4040.

Cafe Marquesa – Choose from a 4-course Turkey Dinner or their regular menu. 600 Fleming Street, (305) 292-1244.

Cafe Sole – Enjoy a full New England-style Thanksgiving dinner or order from the regular menu instead. Open 3pm until 10pm. 1029 Southard Street, (305) 294-0230.

Dante’s – Enjoy their annual All You Can Eat Thanksgiving Buffet! Seating is first come first serve, but you can always have a cocktail by the pool if seating isn’t avail immediately!  955 Caroline Street, (305) 293-5123.

Denny’s – Looking or a good old American diner experience? Order off of the regular menu or enjoy a special turkey dinner instead. 2710 N Roosevelt Blvd, (305) 741-7990.

The Dock’s – The Docks will offer its regular menu as well as a Thanksgiving dinner special. Reservations recommended, walk ins welcome! 6840 Front Street, (305) 396-7049.

Duffy’s Steak and Lobster House – Order from their regular menu or order their Thanksgiving special. 1007 Simonton Street, (305) 296-4900.

First Flight Island Restaurant and Brewery – Order from their full menu or from holiday specials. Reservations are highly recommended. Regular hours all day with their Thanksgiving special available starting at noon. 301 Whitehead Street, (305) 293-8484.

Flagler’s at the Casa Marina Resort – Indulge in a bountiful Thanksgiving buffet at Flagler’s Restaurant, featuring a lavish spread from a charcuterie and chilled seafood display to fresh pasta made-to-order, and carving station with gourmet favorites like Papa’s Pilar Rum glazed turkey, slow-roasted rib roast and miso-butter local fresh catch. Top it off with decadent desserts and more. Celebrate the holiday with oceanfront views and unforgettable flavors! Reservations Recommended for Thursday November 27th at Flagler’s Restaurant. Seating Times: 12:00pm-3:00pm & 5:00pm – 8:00pm. Cost is Adults: $120 | Children $35. Enjoy a Complimentary Welcome Mimosa & Live Music While You Dine.

Four Flamingo’s – A Richard Blais Key West Kitchen at the Hyatt Centric – For $90 per person, enjoy a prix fixe Thanksgiving dinner, served from 2pm until 9pm.

Four Marlins at the Reach Resort – Gather with family and friends at Four Marlins Oceanfront Dining and indulge in a holiday feast like no other. Savor chef-crafted, à la carte Thanksgiving specials paired with sweeping ocean views and the warm island breeze. With live music setting the perfect backdrop on our patio, this is holiday dining in Key West at its finest. Reserve your table now and make this Thanksgiving unforgettable. Reservations Recommended. Thursday November 27th at Four Marlins 5:30pm – 9:30pm – Enjoy Live Music While you Dine!

Frita’s Cuban Burger – Making special Thanksgiving empanadas, burritos, and more! 425 Southard Street, (305) 509-7075.

Grand Cafe – Enjoy their regular menu or a Thanksgiving special. 314 Duval Street, (305) 292-4740.

Hard Rock Cafe – Join us for a feast fit for a VIP! Walk-ins are welcome and guests will be seated on a first come first serve basis. 313 Duval Street, (305) 293-0230.

Hot Tin Roof at the Ocean Key Resort – Gather with our island family for a seasonal and flavorful menu specially curated to celebrate the holidays in Key West. $130++ per person for a delicious four-course menu of traditional Thanksgiving selections. Reservations are required.

Kennedy Cafe – Enjoy their regular menu or a Thanksgiving day special. 924 Kennedy Drive, (305) 809-9000.

Key West Cooking Show – 291 Front Street, Suite 207. Gather your crew and let us take care of the cooking! The Key West Cooking Show is serving a full Thanksgiving dinner on this most American holiday, which, let’s be honest, is all about the food… just like the Key West Cooking Show! Two seatings at 11 am and 3 pm. Enjoy such classics as: Butternut Squash Soup, Bread w/compound butter, Slow Roasted Turkey Breast, Cranberry Sauce, Mashed Potatoes, Sage Stuffing, Homemade Gravy, Green Bean Casserole, Oven Roasted honey-glazed carrots, Pecan Pie. Reservations are required – kwcookingschool@blackdogadvertising.com.

La Te Da – Each year Chef Owner Christopher offers a traditional Thanksgiving dinner. Call for reservations. 1125 Duval Street, (305) 296-6706.

La Trattoria Oceanside – 3593 South Roosevelt Blvd, (305) 295-6789.

La Trattoria Old Town – 524 Duval Street,  (305) 296-1075.

Louie’s Backyard – While closed for lunch on Thanksgiving, they will be opened for dinner starting at 4pm. Reservations and required. 700 Waddell Avenue, (305) 294-1061.

Mac’s Place – They will offer a Thanksgiving dinner option as well as food from their regular menu. 1605 N Roosevelt Drive, (305) 504-3648.

Mangoes – 700 Duval Street, (305) 294-8002.

Martin’s – 917 Duval Street, (305) 295-0111.

Mary Ellen’s – Serving a full Thanksgiving Day feast until it runs out. 420 Appelrouth Lane, (305) 294-7750.

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen and Bar at the Perry Resort & Marina –  7001 Shrimp Road Suite 200, (877) 496-8712.

Nine One Five – Enjoy Thanksgiving Day specials, or the full menu is also available. Space is limited, so reservations are recommended. 915 Duval Street, (305) 296-0669.

Ocean Grill and Bar – Serving a traditional Thanksgiving Day spread as well as their regular menu available. 1075 Duval Street, (305) 296-4300.

Old Town Mexican Cafe – 609 Duval Street, (305) 296-7500.

One Duval at the Pier House Resort and Spa – 1 Duval Street, (305) 296-4600.

Pepe’s Cafe – The oldest restaurant in Key West does Thanksgiving every Thursday, so this day is no exception! 806 Caroline Street, (305) 294-7192.

Prime Steakhouse – 951 Caroline Street, (305) 296-4000.

Ram’s Head Southernmost – 804 Whitehead Street, (305) 440-3196.

Red Shoe Island Bistro – 411 Petronia Street, (305) 509-7271.

Schooner’s Wharf Bar – Enjoy a home-cooked traditional dinner with all the fixings and live music too. 202 William Street, (305) 292-9520.

Southernmost Beach Cafe – 1319 Duval Street, (800) 354-4455.

Tavern N’ Town at the Beachside Resort & Residences – 3841 N Roosevelt Blvd, (305) 296-8100.

Tempt Restaurant at the Saint Hotel – 417 Eaton Street, (305) 294-3200.

Viva Argentinian Steakhouse – Last year there was a Thanksgiving Day special and turkey empanadas, so expect something similar. 903 Duval Street; (305) 741-7666.

Yellowfin Bar and Kitchen at Ocean’s Edge Resort and Marina – 5950 Peninsular Ave, (786) 862-6305.

Catering

If you are local or staying in a vacation rental and don’t want to do the restaurant experience, there are several catering options as well! Whether you just want desserts or the whole shebang cooked for you, here is a list of where to go. Just make sure to put in your orders early. If you want until last minute, you will be out of luck!

Croissants de France – 5620 MacDonald Ave – 305-916-5669 – Selling Thanksgiving Day desserts for you to take home and enjoy. Or, you can enjoy them on site if you prefer! Open from 6:30AM-2:30PM.

DeLuna’s Cafe at Boyd’s Key West Campground – 6401 Maloney Ave, (305) 453-6654.

Destination Catering and Events – Celebrate Thanksgiving in Key West with Destination Catering & Events’ unforgettable island-style feast! Relax and soak up the tropical vibes while our expert team handles every detail of your holiday meal. Our Thanksgiving catering features a delicious menu of classics—juicy roasted turkey, rich savory stuffing, homemade cranberry sauce, and more—each dish prepared with fresh, local Florida Keys ingredients. Whether you’re gathering with a big family or planning a cozy dinner, our catered Thanksgiving dinner is designed to impress. Enjoy professional service, vibrant flavors, and zero kitchen stress—just great food and warm island hospitality. And back by popular demand: our famous Jerk Turkey, the crowd favorite from last year! Make your Thanksgiving in Key West easy, flavorful, and truly memorable—book your catered holiday feast today! For more information, contact us at Telephone: (305) 517-6513, E-mail: Info@destinationcaterer.com, Address: 1111 Eaton Street. Key West, FL 33040.

Eaton Good – Offering a heat and prepared Thanksgiving dinner with everything you need to feed 8-12 people. Free range turkey, mashed potatoes, stuffing, mac and cheese, green bean casserole, dinner rolls, gravy and cranberry sauce, whole roast ham, salad, pumpkin pie. Turkey or whole ham only also available. 1000 Eaton St – (305) 517-6058. 

Fausto’s Food Palace – Gat a fully prepared all natural 8-12 lb Plainville all natural turkey with all of the sides. Or, just get the turkey. 522 Fleming Street, (305) 296-5663 AND 1105 White Street, (305) 294-5221.

Four Marlins Thanksgiving to Go – Bring the flavors of the island home this holiday with our chef-prepared Thanksgiving To-Go Dinner. Perfectly portioned for two, this festive feast features tender herb-marinated turkey with all the traditional trimmings, your choice of five delicious sides, and a sweet finish with homemade pie. View the menu here. Skip the stress, savor the holiday, and let Four Marlins handle the cooking. Place your order by 3pm on Monday, November 24th, and schedule your Thanksgiving Day pick-up between 11am–4pm. Call 305-293-6250 to reserve your meal today.

Great Events Catering – Pick up at 925 Truman Ave (side entrance on Packer Street). Dinner for four is $160 and must be ordered by November 25, 2024. You can add on extras for additional fees. Call to order: (305) 294-2252.

Key West Person Chef and Catering – Thanksgiving Dinner available for pick up between 10:00am – 12:00pm on Thursday, November 27, 2025 from their storefront located at the Lost Kitchen Key West, 6810 Front Street, Stock Island. Each Order will serve between 15 – 20 guests and is $1500.00. Thanksgiving Dinner Menu: Crusty Bakery Bread With Local Honey Butter, Baby Kale and Roasted Pumpkin Salad, Cherries, Pumpkin Seed, pickled Onion, Heirloom Tomato, Fennel and Herb Vinaigrette, Caribbean Spiced Baked Ham With Local Wood Smoke And Pineapple Rum Glaze, Annatto Smoked Whole Turkey With Rosemary Sage And Mango Stuffing, Seagrape – Cranberry Sauce, Citrus Honey glazed Brussel Sprouts with Pecans and Cranberry, Garlic and Chive Buttered Golden Potato, Coconut Creamed Greens and Beans French beans, Collards, Coconut, Crispy Onion, Pumpkin Pecan Pie With Fresh Whipped Cream. For custom orders, please contact us directly at info@keywestpersonalchef.com.

Moondog Cafe and Bakery – 823 Whitehead St – 305-741-7699 – CAKES: Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake (gluten-free), Apple Cake.PIES: Pecan Pie, Berry Pie (vegan), Pumpkin Pie w/Meringue, Sweet Potato Pie, Moondog Key Lime Pie. ORDER YOURS BY EMAILING US: bakery@moondogcafe.com.

Old Town Bakery – 930 Eaton St – 305-396-7450 – Making an assortment of breads for the holiday! 

Publix – 3316 N Roosevelt Blvd – 305-296-2225 OR 1112 Key Plaza – 305-295-8045 – From holiday snacks to a complete turkey dinner, Publix has it all! Don’t want turkey? They also have ham and mojo pork dinner options as well. Must be ordered at least two days in advance. Order in person or online!

Activities in Key West on Thanksgiving

There are so many activities in Key West on Thanksgiving Day to partake it! From going to the beach to taking it easy at your hotel or rental home to enjoying a day of boating. Here are our favorite ideas for the holiday! 

• Check out our listing of Key West sports bars so that you know where you can watch the big Thanksgiving game.
• Dream Catcher Charters offers private fishing charters for the whole family to enjoy! Both Inshore and Offshore! Call Island Genn to reserve your seats – Local: 305-292-7212.
• Toon Time Charters offers private sandbar and snorkeling excursions on a fantastically comfortable boat! Call Island Genn to reserve your seats – Local: 305-292-7212.
• Fury Watersports Ultimate Adventure features sailing, snorkeling, parasailing, jet skiing, and more plus a special holiday menu for both breakfast and lunch including roasted turkey. Thanksgiving Day from 10am until 4pm for $160 plus tax per person.  Call Island Genn to reserve your seats – Local: 305-292-7212.
• Sunset Watersports Sunset Dinner Cruise features a traditional turkey dinner while on the water. Our team prepares and cooks the food in our onboard kitchen, which makes sure the food is fresh and delicious. This trip also includes an unlimited open well bar. Grab a beverage and groove into the sunset as our local musician fills the air with tropical vibes. $100 per person plus tax. Call Island Genn to reserve your seats – Local: 305-292-7212.

Events in Key West Over the Thanksgiving Holiday

There are also a few events in Key West over the Thanksgiving holiday. Some are holiday themed while others are not. But they are all sure to be a good time.

• Live Music at Dorada | Live Entertainment Nightly | 6pm to 9pm – Soak up the vibrant sounds of live music as you sip cocktails by the beach. Our weekly performers set the tone for laid-back luxury with an eclectic mix of tunes, perfect for unwinding after a day of exploring.
• Beach Pickleball | Wednesday-Sunday | West Beach – Dive into a breezy twist on the classic game – played right on the sand for a feel that’s part pickleball, part beach volleyball. Rental gear is available at the Family Pool Recreation Stand.
• Family Friendly Fun | Friday-Saturday | 12pm-3pm | Family Pool & Beach – Stop by for a rotating lineup of crafts, games, and activities designed to keep the whole family smiling and entertained all afternoon long. Fun for kids and adults alike!
• Live Music on Four Marlins Patio Thursday Nov. 27^th 5pm – 9pm, Saturday & Sunday Nov. 29th-30th 10am-2pm.
• Four Marlins Leftover Brunch – Keep the holiday spirit going all weekend long with our festive Leftover Brunch at Four Marlins. Enjoy bottomless mimosas, chef-inspired à la carte selections, and decadent desserts, all served with sweeping ocean views. Saturday & Sunday Nov. 29th-30th at Four Marlins 7:00am-2:00pm. Live Music from 10:00am-2:00pm. Reservations Recommended.
• Southernmost Turkey Trot – Thursday, November 27, 2025 – The 1400 block of Duval will be closed beginning at 5:00am, where the race starts and ends. There will be rolling street closures through the race route. CLICK HERE for more information.
• 2025 Lighting of The Bight: Key West Harbor Walk of Lights – Thursday, November 27, 2025 6:00 PM – 8:00 PM  EST at the Key West Historic Seaport on Greene & Elizabeth Street. The Key West “Harbor Walk of Lights” traditional main features will light up the night, including the 20’ Fishing Buoy Tree, a 16’ Nautical Christmas Tree and the original Key West Lobster Trap Tree. Lights come on at 6:00pm, holiday music starts at 5:00pm. LOCATION: The Harbor Walk plaza at Greene and Elizabeth St. for the best view.
• Tropical Forest & Botanical Garden: 6th Annual Scarecrows in the Forest Art Exhibit – Monday, September 1, 2025 10:00 AM – Sunday, November 30, 2025 4:00 PM EST at the Key West Botanical Garden Society located 5210 College Road, Key West, FL 33040. Get your spooky on at the 7th annual Scarecrows in the Forest Art exhibition and Contest. Around the corner, in a meadow or right in front of you, made from natural, recycled and repurposed material, scarecrows are found throughout the Tropical Forest & Botanical Garden. The exhibit runs Sept. 1-Nov. 30. Create your own Scarecrow for exhibition and prizes!  The Garden welcomes visitors to view the Scarecrow Exhibit created by local artists and students which are scattered throughout the Garden and Forest.  Visitors can vote for their favorite.  Cash prizes will be awarded. Contact Misha McRAE at mmcrae@keywest.garden or call him at 305-296-1501 for more information.

More About Key West

Do you want to know more about Key West? And, I know you want to make the holiday the best it can be. So, before making your restaurant reservations for Thanksgiving Day, be sure to read my restaurant reviews. And, check out our restaurant review section of this blog. Also, to see what is happening on the island during your visit, check out our Key West Events Calendar to see other upcoming special events. For more information about the fun side of Key West… things to do and see in our island city, go to our Key West Web Site.

Feel free to Email Me if you have any questions about Key West!!

Island Genn – Your Key West Concierge