Christmas Dinner Key West 2023

As a foodie, meals are one of the more important parts of the holidays for me. So, when I am going someplace new, I want to know the best places to eat. Below is our listing of restaurants offering Christmas specials in Key West. (The list is not exhaustive, and it will be updated throughout the month as information becomes available). 

In addition, check out my restaurant reviews as most eateries stay open throughout the holidays. Restaurants do sell out on Christmas. Therefore, I highly recommend making reservations this time of year well in advance. You can make reservations for most of these restaurants at Open Table.

Please reach out to me at if you are a restaurant/business that wants to be featured. Provide all the details of your holiday offering in your message. 


A & B Lobster House – 700 Front Street. 305-294-5880.

Alonzo’s Oyster Bar – 700 Front Street. 305-600-3405

Antonia’s – 615 Duval Street. 305-294-6565.

Atlas Izakaya – 500 Truman Avenue. 305-998-4189.

AZUR – 425 Grinnell Street. 305-292-2987.

Bagatelle – 115 Duval Street. 305-296-6609.

Bel Mare – 700 Front Street. 305-396-4040.

Benihana – 3591 S Roosevelt Boulevard. 305-294-6400.

Bistro 245 at the Opal Key Resort – 245 Front Street. 305-294-4000.

Cafe Marquesa – 600 Fleming Street. 305-292-1244.

Cafe Sole – 1029 Southard Street. 305-294-0230. Open 3 – 10pm. Serving special menu on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. Slow Roasted Goose with homemade stuffing, foie gras and plums, natural gravy and 6 traditional sides OR Prime Rib with black truffle au jus. Limited regular Manu also available on these days.

First Flight Island Restaurant & Brewery – 301 Whitehead Street. 305-293-8484.

Flagler’s Restaurant at the Casa Marina – 1500 Reynolds Street. 305-296-3535. Offering their annual Christmas Day Buffet, priced at $115 per person. 

Four Flamingos, A Richard Blais Key West Kitchen – 601 Front Street. 305-809-4000. Reservations are available from 5 pm to 8:30 pm.  Priced at $85 per person.

Four Marlins at the Reach Resort – 1435 Simonton Street. 305-293-6250.

Christmas Papas Pilar
Holiday Nog courtesy of Papa’s Pilar Rum. Celebrating Christmas with a classic.

Grand Cafe – 314 Duval Street. 305-292-4740.

La Te Da – 1125 Duval Street. 305-296-6706.

La Trattoria – Oceanside – 3593 S Roosevelt Blvd. 305-295-6789.

Hard Rock Cafe – 313 Duval Street. 305-293-0230. Offering a special 3-course meal for the month of December.  Priced at $48.95 per person.

Hot Tin Roof at the Ocean Key Resort – 0 Duval Street. 305-295-7057. Offering a special Christmas Day menu for $130 ++ per person.

Mangoes – 700 Duval Street. 305-294-8002.

Martin’s – 917 Duval Street. 305-295-0111.

Matt’s Stock Island Kitchen & Bar at the Perry – 7001 Shrimp Road. 877-496-8712. 3-course Christmas dinner is $99 per person.

Milagro Restaurant & Bar – 1401 Simonton Street. 305-440-3534.

New York Pasta Garden – 1075 Duval Street. 305-292-1991.

Nine One Five – 915 Duval Street. 305-296-0669.

Ocean Grill – 1075 Duval Street. 305-296-4300.

Off the Hook Grill – 920 Caroline Street. 305-741-7980. Open 4 -9ish with live music from 4-6pm.

One Duval at the Pier House – 1 Duval Street. 305-295-3255. The Christmas Eve & Christmas Day menu included: Roasted Beet & Goat Cheese Salad $14 OR Lobster Bisque $14. Surf & Turf $75 OR Havana Style Kurobuta Pork $44. Bourbon Pecan Pie $10.

Southernmost Beach Cafe – 1405 Duval Street. 305-295-6550. Offering their regular menu as well as a special Family-Style meal. This menu will be $65++ per person and includes 1 bottle of house wine per 2 adults. The menu will be available from 4pm to close.

Tavern N Town at the Marriott Beachside Resort – 3841 N Roosevelt Blvd. 305-296-8100. Tavern N Town will be open from 4pm to 11pm with dinner service ending at 10pm on Christmas Day. Due to the holiday, Tapas and Happy Hours will be unavailable. Reservations are highly suggested. A specialty dinner menu will be available including Butternut Squash Bisque, Roasted Porchetta Stuffed with House Sausage, and Eggnog Bread Pudding. The full menu with also be available.

Viva Argentinean – 903 Duval Street. 305-783-2602.

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen at Ocean’s Edge Resort & Marina – 5950 Peninsular Avenue. Celebrate the magic of Christmas this year with a beautiful dining experience at Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen, where we invite you to indulge in our exclusive Prix Fixe Dinner. Nestled along the picturesque waterfront, Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen offers a breathtaking backdrop for a festive Christmas gathering. Our coastal-inspired decor and warm ambiance create the perfect setting to share the joy of the holiday season with your loved ones. Our attentive staff is committed to ensuring your dining experience is nothing short of magical. Let us take care of every detail, from the warm hospitality to the impeccable service, so you can fully savor the joy of the season. – Starters – Seafood Stew with chayote, clams, mussels, shrimp, fish, potatoes. Wedge Salad with pancetta, gorgonzola, pickled red onion, and homemade ranch. – Main – Prime Rib with fingerling potatoes, grilled asparagus and au jus. Chicken Cordon Bleu with herb cheese mashed potatoes, broccolini, and fresh herb velouté. Almond Encrusted Grouper with butternut squash purée, Swiss chard, and blood orange Poema buerre blanc. Roasted Cauliflower Steak with smoky roasted carrot purée and butter bean dip with pesto. – Dessert – Cranberry White Chocolate Cheesecake. Chocolate Pots de Crème Panna Cotta. $95 per person. Call +1 (877) 935-0862 to make a reservation. TO GO orders are available with advance notice. Please let us know via the number above. Same price applies.

Catering / Do it Yourself 

Fausto’sPlace your Christmas orders at the Deli by Dec 18th. Turkey Dinner $179.99. Cuban Pork Dinner $ 99.99. Two locations: 522 Fleming Street • 305-296-5663 and 1105 White Street • 305-294-5221. Fausto’s is open Monday – Sunday 7:30am-7pm.

More About Key West

Do you want to know more about our island? Visit all the different sections of this blog. Additionally, you can check out our sister site, for lots of information on other Key West activities, not Christmas related! 

In closing, I hope you have a great Holiday! 

Island Genn – Key West Concierge

About the author: Island Genn

Related Posts